5472 Chem. Soc. Rev., 2011, 40, 5472–5491 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011
Cite this: Chem. Soc. Rev., 2011, 40, 5472–5491
Fabrication and application of inorganic hollow spheres
Jing Hu,ab Min Chen,a Xiaosheng Fanga and Limin Wu*a
Received 25th April 2011
DOI: 10.1039/c1cs15103g
Inorganic hollow spheres have attracted considerable interest due to their singular properties and
wide range of potential applications. In this critical review, we provide a comprehensive overview
of the preparation and applications of inorganic hollow spheres. We first discuss the syntheses of
inorganic hollow spheres by use of polymers, inorganic nonmetals, metal-based hard templates,
small-molecule emulsion, surfactant micelle-based soft-templates, and the template-free approach.
For each method, a critical comment is given based on our knowledge and related research
experience. We go on to discuss some important applications of inorganic hollow spheres in 0D,
2D, and 3D arrays. We conclude this review with some perspectives on the future research and
development of inorganic hollow spheres (235 references).
1. Introduction
Monodisperse hollow spheres have attracted considerable
interest in the past few decades due to their well-defined
morphology, uniform size, low density, large surface area,
and wide range of potential applications. For instance, the
large fraction of void space in hollow structures has been used
to load and control releasing systems for special materials,
such as drugs, genes, peptides, spiceries, and biological mole-
cules.1 They can also be used to modulate refractive index,
lower density, increase the active area for catalysis and
adsorption, improve particles’ ability to withstand cyclic
changes in volume, and expand the array of imaging markers
suitable for early detection of cancer.2,3
Inorganic hollow spheres have special optical, optoelectronic,
magnetic, electrical, thermal, electrochemical, photoelectro-
chemical, mechanical, and catalytic properties, suggesting that
they comprise a more common, more diverse, and probably
richer class of materials than organic hollow spheres.4
Beginning with the pioneering work carried out by Kowalski
and colleagues at Rohm and Haas,5,6 a variety of chemical and
physicochemical strategies, including heterophase polymerization/
combined with a sol–gel process,7 emulsion/interfacial
polymerization methods,8–10 self-assembly techniques,11,12
and surface living polymerization process13–15 have been
aDepartment of Materials Science and the Key Laboratory of
Molecular Engineering of Polymers of MOE, Fudan University,
Shanghai 200433, P. R. China. E-mail: lmw@fudan.edu.cn
b School of Perfume and Aroma Technology, Shanghai Institute of
Technology, Shanghai 200235, China
Jing Hu
Jing Hu received her PhD
degree from Shaanxi Univer-
sity of Science and Techno-
logy in July, 2009. Then, she
joined the School of Perfume
and Aroma Technology of
Shanghai Institute of Techno-
logy as a lecturer in perfume
and aroma technology. In
2010, she was awarded
‘‘Shanghai Chenguang Scholar’’
by Shanghai municipality. Her
current research interests
include preparation and assem-
bly of nanocapsules, function
mechanism of sustained fra-
grance and propagation fibers.
Min Chen
Min Chen received her PhD
degree from Fudan University
under the supervision of
Professor Limin Wu in 2006.
Her dissertation was chosen as
one of the ‘‘Top 100 National
Excellent Doctoral Disserta-
tions’’ in 2008. Just after
finishing the doctorate work,
she joined the Department of
Materials Science, Fudan
University, and was succes-
sively awarded ‘‘Shanghai
Chenguang Scholar’’ and
‘‘Rising Star’’ by Shanghai
municipality. She is currently
an Associate Professor. Her research interests include the
synthesis, characterization, assembly and properties of novel
organic–inorganic hybrid nanostructured materials and
inorganic hollow spheres.
Chem Soc Rev Dynamic Article Links
www.rsc.org/csr CRITICAL REVIEW
D
ow
nl
oa
de
d
by
T
ia
nji
n U
niv
ers
ity
on
22
N
ov
em
be
r 2
01
1
Pu
bl
ish
ed
o
n
29
Ju
ly
2
01
1
on
h
ttp
://
pu
bs
.rs
c.o
rg
| d
oi:
10.
10
39/
C1
CS
151
03G
View Online / Journal Homepage / Table of Contents for this issue
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 Chem. Soc. Rev., 2011, 40, 5472–5491 5473
employed to prepare inorganic hollow spheres. In particular,
the template method is the most common. In this method, at
least two steps are usually indispensable. First, the templates
must be modified to give them the ability to coax inorganic
precursors (salts or alkoxides) onto the surface of the template
core. Then, after the inorganic shell is decorated outside the
scaffold, the templates must be eliminated in some way,
leaving behind a hollow shell. Generally, templates can be
divided into hard and soft templates. When hard templates
(e.g., SiO2,
16–18 C spheres,19 polymers,20–24 metal particles25)
are employed, the structure of the hollow product is similar to
that of the template, with a well-defined and monodisperse
morphology. However, the removal of the templates by either
thermal (sintering) or chemical (etching) means is very com-
plicated and energy-consuming. As for soft templates
(bacteria,26,27 droplets,28 vesicles29,30 and more), although it
is relatively easier to remove the templates, the morphology
and monodispersity of the as-prepared hollow products are
usually poor due to the deformability of the soft template.
Although the drawbacks in these template strategies seem to
be inherent and insurmountable, some novel techniques that
seem to overcome them, such as sacrificial templates, modified
soft templates, etc., are emerging. Another important devel-
opment in the preparation of inorganic hollow spheres is
called the template-free method, such as the Ostwald ripening
process, which not only combines the advantages of hard- and
soft-template methods but also avoids their pitfalls. Recent
reviews have provided a comprehensive description of these
methods for fabrication of inorganic hollow spheres,
from multilevel hollow spheres to non-spherical, even one-
dimensional (1D) hollow structures.4,31–34
In order to avoid overlapping reviews, this article will
mainly focus on the syntheses and applications of inorganic
hollow spheres rather than any non-spherical and 1D hollow
structures. We will first discuss the syntheses of inorganic
hollow spheres with polymer, inorganic nonmetal, and
metal-based hard templates and small-molecule or oligomer
emulsion, surfactant micelle-based soft-templates, and template-
free approaches. For each method, we provide critical
comments based on our knowledge and related research
experience. Then we will introduce some important applica-
tions of the inorganic hollow spheres (0D) and two-
dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) arrays of
inorganic hollow spheres. Considering the rapidly expanding
body of literature in the field, the list of examples provided in
this review is by no means exhaustive, some excellent papers
reporting novel approaches and applications are even omitted.
Representative works were selected from the most recent
literature available, with exceptions made only for special
cases. The intent is to give the readers a critical discussion of
the syntheses and applications of inorganic hollow spheres.
Finally, we conclude this review with some perspectives on the
future research and development of inorganic hollow spheres.
2. Hard template strategy
Hard templates are widely used to fabricate inorganic hollow
spheres. Many compounds, such as polymeric, inorganic
nonmetallic, and metallic particles, can be used as hard
templates. The final shape and size of the inorganic hollow
sphere are essentially dependent upon the templates.
2.1 Polymer template-based methods
Templating against polymer colloids is probably the most
common approach to produce hollow spheres. Two methods
in particular are used to fabricate hollow spheres with homo-
geneous, dense layers. One is templating against colloid poly-
styrene (PS) and its derivatives as the particles to fabricate
SiO2,
35 SnO2,
36 magnet (ccp-Co, hcp-Co, Co3O4, a-Fe, Fe3O4
and a-Fe2O3),
37,38 metal–metalloid Ni–B,39 Ni(OH)2,
40 and
others.41,42 In its typical procedure, the PS template particles
are coated in solution either by controlled surface precipita-
tion of inorganic molecule precursors (SiO2, TiO2, etc.) or by
Xiaosheng Fang
Xiaosheng Fang received his
PhD degree from the Institute
of Solid State Physics,
Chinese Academy of Sciences
in 2006, under the supervision
of Professor Lide Zhang. He
joined the National Institute
for Materials Science
(NIMS), Japan, as a JSPS
postdoctoral fellow and then
the International Center for
Young Scientists (ICYS)—
International Center for
Materials Nanoarchitectonics
(MANA) as a researcher.
Currently, he is professor at
the Department of Materials Science, Fudan University, China.
His current research topic is the controlled fabrication, novel
properties and optoelectronic applications of semiconductor
nanostructures, with a focus on II–VI inorganic semiconductor
nanostructures-based optoelectronic devices.
Limin Wu
Limin Wu received his PhD
degree from Zhejiang Univer-
sity in 1991. He worked as a
lecturer then an associate pro-
fessor from 1991 to 1994. He
worked as a visiting professor
at Pennsylvania State Univer-
sity and Eastern Michigan
University from 1994 to
1999. He joined Fudan Uni-
versity in 1999, where he
currently is ‘‘Changjiang
Scholar’’ Professor awarded
by the Ministry of Education
of China. His current research
interests include synthesis,
assembly and photoelectric properties of organic–inorganic
nanoparticles, hollow inorganic particles, development of
functional coatings and films.
D
ow
nl
oa
de
d
by
T
ia
nji
n U
niv
ers
ity
on
22
N
ov
em
be
r 2
01
1
Pu
bl
ish
ed
o
n
29
Ju
ly
2
01
1
on
h
ttp
://
pu
bs
.rs
c.o
rg
| d
oi:
10.
10
39/
C1
CS
151
03G
View Online
5474 Chem. Soc. Rev., 2011, 40, 5472–5491 This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011
direct surface reactions utilizing specific functional groups on
the cores to create core-shell composites. The PS template
particles are then removed by selective dissolution in an
appropriate solvent or by calcination at elevated temperature
in air, leaving behind hollow spheres. Bourgeat-Lami et al.
synthesized PS latex particles bearing silanol groups on the
surface via emulsion polymerization using 3-(trimethoxysily)
propyl methacrylate as a functional co-monomer.43 These PS
colloids were then transferred into aqueous ethanol solution
by solvent exchange, wherein the co-condensation of the
silanol groups with tetraethoxysilane (TEOS) was carried
out via an ammonia-catalyzed sol–gel process, causing
composite particles with PS cores and SiO2 shells. Hollow
SiO2 spheres were obtained by thermal degradation of the PS
cores at 600 1C. Yang and Lu et al. first described a new
approach to the generation of inorganic hollow spheres using
a template of the core-shell PS gel particles synthesized by an
inward sulfonation with concentrated sulfuric acid.44 They
also successfully prepared double-shelled TiO2 spheres with a
kind of special hollow spheres polymer as a template.45,46 This
special hollow template composite was composed of hollow PS
spheres containing a thin hydrophilic inner layer and trans-
verse channels of poly (methyl methacrylate)–poly
(methacrylic acid) (PMMA–PMA). As shown in Fig. 1, when
the hollow sphere template was first treated with sulfuric acid,
the sulfonation took place in the exterior shell surface, the
interior shell surface, and the transverse channels. This sulfo-
nation of the hollow spheres enhanced the hydrophilicity of
the spheres and provided a suitable graft surface for adsorp-
tion or forming complexes with a large variety of functional
components, such as metal ions, metal oxide precursors, and
organic precursors. Using TiO2 as an example, the sulfonated
hollow spheres were immersed into a Ti(OBu)4 sol to coat a
layer onto both the inner and outer interfaces of the hollow
spheres. The existence of PMMA–PMA transverse channels
on the PS shell acted as the entrance for the TiO2 sol. The
double-shelled TiO2 hollow spheres were obtained after the
intermediate PS layer was removed by a solvent. Following a
similar procedure, the same authors successfully prepared
carbon,47 TiO2, BaTiO3 and SrTiO3 hollow spheres.
48
Ma et al. used porous polystyrene–divinyl-benzene (PS–DVB)
spheres as templates to synthesize multi-shelled spheres and
sphere-in-sphere structures by modifying the post-calcination
process.49 The temperature during the preheating process directly
affects the final structures of TiO2 spheres. Except for using PS
and its derivatives as templates, melamine formaldehyde can also
be used to prepare hollow spheres based on noble metal oxides
and magnetic oxides.50
Another method, termed the layer-by-layer (LbL) self-
assembly technique, has become an attractive topic of investi-
gation ever since it was first developed by Caruso et al.51,52
The principle of this process is based on the electrostatic
association between alternately deposited, oppositely charged
species. Multilayered shells are assembled onto submicrometer-
sized colloidal PS particles by the sequential adsorption of
polyelectrolytes and oppositely charged nanoparticles. Upon
calcination of the obtained core-shell particles, uniform-sized
hollow spheres of various diameters and wall thicknesses can
be generated from a variety of inorganic materials, including
SiO2,
51,52 TiO2,
53 Mn2O3,
54 zeolite,55 and other materials.56
In polymer template-based methods for preparation of
inorganic hollow spheres, the biggest advantage is that the
polymer templates are easily prepared with controllable sizes
and surface functional groups, thus many hollow spheres of
nonmetallic oxides, metallic oxides, and even metals can be
fabricated through this approach. However, the preparation
processes can require a lot of energy and time. First, multi-step
processes are required for the synthesis of core-shell composite
particles, e.g., the surface-functionalization of templating
particles and the exchange of solvent/coating reaction in
the templating particle approach and repeated adsorption/
centrifugation/washing/redispersion cycles in the LbL method.
Second, in order to obtain hollow spheres from core-shell
composite particles, removing the core particles by selective
dissolution in an appropriate solvent or by calcination at
elevated temperature in air is indispensable.
Recently, Wu et al. reported a one-step process of fabricat-
ing monodisperse hollow SiO2 and TiO2 spheres. This means
the formation of the inorganic shells and dissolution of core
polymer particles occurs in the same medium (Fig. 2).57–60 In
this method, monodisperse, positively charged PS beads were
prepared by dispersion polymerization using cationic
monomer 2-(methacryloyl) ethyltrimethylammonium chloride
as co-monomer, which ensures the resulting silica or titania
nanoparticles from the hydrolysis and condensation of TEOS
or tetra-n-butyl titanate could be rapidly captured by PS beads
Fig. 1 Illustration of the formation of double-shelled hollow spheres.
(a) The sulfonated polymer hollow sphere templates; (b) titania
composite hollow spheres; (c) doubled-shelled titania hollow spheres.
Reprinted with permission from ref. 45. Copyright 2005 Wiley-VCH.
Fig. 2 Schematic illustrations of SiO2 (a), TiO2 (b) and ZnO (c)
hollow spheres prepared via one-step process.
D
ow
nl
oa
de
d
by
T
ia
nji
n U
niv
ers
ity
on
22
N
ov
em
be
r 2
01
1
Pu
bl
ish
ed
o
n
29
Ju
ly
2
01
1
on
h
ttp
://
pu
bs
.rs
c.o
rg
| d
oi:
10.
10
39/
C1
CS
151
03G
View Online
This journal is c The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 Chem. Soc. Rev., 2011, 40, 5472–5491 5475
via electrostatic interaction in aqueous ammoniacal alcohol
medium at 50 1C. Very interestingly, the PS beads are
‘‘dissolved’’ into PS macromolecule chains or their aggregates
subsequently, even synchronously, in the same medium, and
are further diffused out gradually through the silica or titania
shells since the silica or titania shells prepared by the Sto¨ber
method are usually porous, directly forming hollow SiO2 or
TiO2 spheres. Neither additional dissolution nor calcination
processes are needed to remove the PS cores. If negatively
charged PS beads are used as templates, then ZnO or even
Ag/SiO2 double-shelled hollow spheres could also be prepared
based on the one-step method.61,62 If this coating process
occurs under acidic circumstances, PS/SiO2 hybrid hollow
spheres and PS/rare-earth-doped nanocrystals (LaF3: Eu
3+,
LaF3: Ce
3+–Tb3+, and YVO4: Dy
3+) hybrid hollow spheres
could be directly obtained via a one-pot synthesis, in which the
PS macromolecular chains diffused from core into the voids
between inorganic nanoparticles driven by the strong capillary
force to form hybrid shells. This organic–inorganic hybrid
shell is expected to improve the mechanical properties of
inorganic hollow spheres.63,64
2.2 Inorganic nonmetallic template-based methods
Inorganic nonmetallic templates mainly include carbon and
silica particles. Carbon spheres appear to be particularly
suitable for templating due to their rich reactive groups and
ease of removal. Many uniform micro/nano-sized hollow
spheres of metallic oxides such as VO2,
65 Gd2O3: Ln (Ln =
Eu3+, Sm3+), Ga2O3, NiO, MnO2
66 and so on,67 have been
fabricated using carbonaceous polysaccharide spheres as the
templates. The surfaces of the carbonaceous microspheres,
prepared from saccharide starting materials by dehydration
under hydrothermal conditions, are hydrophilic and functiona-
lized with –OH and CQO groups. Upon dispersal of the
carbonaceous microspheres in metal salt solutions, the func-
tional groups on the surface layer are able to bind metal cations
through coordination or electrostatic interactions. In the
subsequent calcination process, the surface layers incorporating
the cationic metal ions are condensed and cross-linked to form
oxide hollow spheres. For example, Yang and co-workers
reported that hollow Gd2O3: Ln (Ln = Eu
3+, Sm3+) micro-
spheres with diameters of about 300 nm were successfully
fabricated by using carbon spheres as templates.68 As shown
in Fig. 3a, when the precipitation agent, urea, was dissolved in
water, it decomposed into CO2 and OH
�, coupled with a large
number of –OH bonds on the surfaces of the carbon spheres. In
the coating process, Gd3+ and Ln3+ were easily precipitated on
the surfaces of carbon spheres. Then the high crystallization of
Gd2O3: Ln (Fig. 3b) was formed and the carbon spheres were
removed at a calcination temperature of 700 1C. This fabrica-
tion process involves neither organic compounds nor etching
agents.
Li and co-workers prepared Ga2O3 and GaN semiconductor
hollow spheres, ranging from 100 nm to 1.5 mm in size, by
adsorption of metal cations to the surface layer of hydrophilic
carbon (carbonaceous polysaccharide) spheres with copious
–OH groups, followed by calcination in air.69,70 They then
extended this method to prepare hollow spheres from a wide
range of metal oxides, including main group metal oxides
(Al2O3, SnO2), transition metal oxides (ZrO2, TiO2, CoO,
NiO, Cr2O3, Mn3O4), and rare earth oxides (La2O3, Y2O3,
Lu2O3, CeO2).
71 Suslick et al. reported a sonochemical fabri-
cation of crystalline hollow hematite (R-Fe2O3) using carbon
nanoparticles as a spontaneously removable template for
nanosized hollow core formation.72
In order to simplify the preparation of inorganic hollow
spher