神之定位

+ffi . tt A#t:T++rBtrt. 'ftR#IgS8!8tr+Ttfi HWff i HT= nH"EElE ffi*f ffi ' frrA ( Karl Rahner, 1904-1984 >.Hr ffl I€AH€ I ( metaphysical anthropology ) yZ r Hffi+FPAffi€ .r ( fundamental-theological anthropology ) + ' Sl+F fr(1fr.ffi.frtrr|UWf. trfifr,Zffifr!,E ffi * ffiE+.Z#ffitr Pfr! Fdffi E ? Ef*-d.i.iEfE Fd ffiffJffi$ffi ' Htb,il,rEltHlF& nffiI+FgF-€#fr.ffiffi , fr.|re ffiE'RtrrffiE+ ' Ff,ffi tfr,ffiffiflJZRRflBliffii *thHfft r ffi ruffffiWfr.ffrt Z+ ' fiH^Hffi€' ffEFf&ffiffi+lJtrlBtr,flz ,8,€mD/#tt' D,{ltH fu{m zrfrH FITtrl i ffi&HBFffi H{fr ro Z+tF , EEEIDlMRfl,efUffiffiflJz&.Mflfr!#tFF6ffi " F tr, #yfftfrTtlj =HtrlmD/Hs : H .F{+MfrnFE#€{f++ il . &roffaruzBf H!,E,ffixFltF zfr.{fr.wffiflJ 4 . fr.n$lffi ffJfr.{fr.ftA Ef ffi i{ ffiffi ffi,+tJ 28 ffi.Xfr! fdffi A+/\E*tstr*89)ffiHD/Ft ' #f#F{$Are r iqf .r iE'lE# ffiHleHf$Z'F rffie t ,4#*E9]ffiffiffiffi' f,ffFiEP5e ----' rsz Ffi,qr,,) *ed:.fr{.?{M#f 6t E€.ffi+ ffifsH | #ffiq€., ' " +;ftx a&r*F*: ffiruFjffi ffJfr,ltfrtr trl D^ffilR | #ffiE 4 t Flfdffi , ffi)Ftrvro SJffi frrJfr,|fr frtr'd D) ffii^ rffie.r Flfdffi ' EEtrHtrWfrE#.E9rffitrZtkfrtrH. M,X ' HffiFfffr.ffiWef$E r#ffiE€r ffiTE r++e: " T )E tr HA ro X?S, H E Eifr fi!,H ffi frF.fAE{*Eff Htr z'Hf H! ,Hffi , FfrD} ' fHBflfl( '}IhXIEffiHffiEffiftFf ffiffi Zf6;H ' D/ R#H'IRHffiM" E. H.ItMfrru=E*fEfi?H ffi l+ rfifr.ru 4 E # fr.[fi+#nE ? Effi tE W,ffitrtLzffik!,B ffi X, fiHfttr +fr,+EW +t\EFn ffi Tt ffi #reffi e4 #ffiE 4, trfr.{t+FffiE4T -tt.Frfr ' €ffzrE+FH!trHH H ffiit?fis ffi ' m-AAfr! r lffi'l+.1 ( subjectivity ) A+frffi,K ' mD)' fE$+ff iEtrb#ffihnDlH +, if i#,HflHre+E H #fr!f; ffiE eE m, E #fr.lfr+F , D)ffi*tuFnwH,frlr6ffi " ffi ru zBt fr!,E ffi,xtr fr.{fr+fiffi ' r.} ffi AHffi ffiFn#EW EffiTIE ' E-JFFtr"ffi T4,Eh.r f[ TH,I4 I ffi,IEEE " {ET€E fftH'lS,B frtrfrkJftE ( @,tfr: xtffEffi+He . rg'rsi# e.E*Egrwffi 2 | H*R+H-#., ) 4R'Hffimffi frE ( E+f; : H#i#-{={4+#ffit* e . _R X,Efitfr4 HE! #ffiffiffip.ffiffi ffi e ) ft.ffr+F$, ffiS{...?. EIJE+.T - f*FJ, ixa€ Fl+Ffi+ifi fr!#ffi 4H ft i* tfrrfrffi | fr# €.59. ft! rffiffi'l+.1 (spirituality) ' rffiffi'Ell (transcendentality) . rm ffi!y*..1 (openness) &. rlE-R'Elr (historicity)lf i .KW i *,A€fi E4;f! tr HHiE?fi *ffi. " Fn D), T'Elf...'$ffi firy ffi,frrc ^ H H glryrn, K#ff ip.p) (h)v,z HEff i#,1994 ) , l l11 " + F . *i dJ *ttf ff R-4a z ft.R *E + htt A Ez++rr I 53 hffi*ffi€ffitrJF?.Wd ' lE4[ffiruFftE : r rX,,f\j.#, RbLE +*tt+if ;tfrU,#*. rqLlt,,F.} htW-#fr* , 'l*-4+Bfrq lx'f ,x 4tr xa hnfr+*n re-fr.1Er68,h E t', m.affif+ frtF zHjffi# ffii*etftEHHfr!BAI{R" Ef Itr 'WH trtrffiffi fr!ffitf'EtAH ' fr.Ufr,ffiHffi , W+$+F,F E^H ffi ffi FNEItr.T*tr.HH tr +KFNIIE EffiSH' rntr+4ffiff i82\F!trHHiE' ffeUftE Fi+Z fdf!trffiEflFl " &ro #ffi , ED) r ffiffifr! I ( thematic ) 3,HfffffiAf#-E*.JiFffi ' tt tr /F 11 fr.f$ffi,Yt Lryffits.H E tnWFH Z#.ffi F! ftE f.lm #fi ' iE4[ &ffiffi ( rhomas Aquinas, r22s-r2741 FF*trf,! : r if &1i4*.in A' # 6 # fi" FAt+ 4 6 # Z4+ + hl +18., r&..4-T € ft-- fiE*t#+,S ,A,\fi.: fr +fr.: *i ?o, o ; ?t lE ffi &E fi!ffi'l+ #trffiffi+tr, m+lJ t#fFl-#f f* " E))) r /Ff f f ! r (unthematic) 5, i ' f f f #E{ffi ' ttff tFrlEHH ffir=-lqww#-m E ; ruE[E ttrIfl EffiffiffiWfrT+aElH " a - Hiirer Des Wortes: Zur Grundlegung einer Religionsphilosophie,Neu bearbeitet von J. B. Metz ( Miinchen: Kdsel-Verlag, 1963 ) , pp.r3e-145. ffiru#H ' EEIffiR'llf tr!ffi?+EH ,fUtrlEffi'l+fr! tr FS,i( ff & E m R ft H! tU F.d' m D), ffi SJ EI fiU,frtJ E r< H! tt FJ' ,i(itm.E,Z'ttE flER " {e Hft f.##ffiE €.'N#.ffi r ffi H #frffiS r EffiEI6U,WfrEfifr!'Uff " ' t ffiffiF!: H.fEffiffi fttfrffivJ-truqgr!fi# , ilFpffitr€m+ffiH!ffi fif "+FlffifffffiH Baker-Hang' (ffiEf! > ,frEtr& ( W.Brugger) m*, (tr i+freff i4) ( tr iEffiff i#, h)f,: #6H ,ree2) , 451F" o Hriru des Wortes : Zur Grundlegung einer Religionsphilosophie, p.20. " tFffiffifi! r HfEf*ffi#+-qEEffiaz#ffi T:frtflFfiffiaH!ff# " #ilffi{ffffiH Baker-Hang ' HfrdlI " -__/ rs4 Ffi4+ *zA.fr*.i*.n&*effi s.€.t#+ fl . fr N}fr+ljHl^ffiffi.A#ilffi ZEfi fr ru E Kg FfrlfHHA ) +' S+FIA +AZffifr+r-sPirrfr! ,E mffi frffiflJ, tLmffiFJfr\4trr'Rffits,+fr : r Xl ffi*W+qe ,E'ffir ' rEJS+#,E,ffir ' rtr#EglffiffiZr H#ffii-fr1 ,8 ffi r ' | #ffi.Rffi.E e,E m t h. r Hffi +#-{F{4t# ( positivist-fideistic ) H!ffi€,Bffi: " E#HrEH'ffiH.W.E!#EFtt ft , Eftf*i.dEtg .€trs.28 ffi+ffi , t*#F+EHfyE frrnfil+ft fU " eH 7trlftWtl m I SlXtAtHreffi e,B ffi XFI+F Zfr.ffi.$r ffiflJ t' r FJE'l$+#frtr*EF]ffiffift! r H*+Fi-ft r,Bffi* FtiS 2fr.{:)LfrtJffiFl t' I Wffiffi#ffiE e,E,ffi XF}+fi Zfr.tfr.frrJ ffiFJ t h- r SlHffi + #-{Ef4 i# fr!ffi e,Bffi *S}ffi Zfr.{fr.tr'r ffiflJ t WfliJl ' E-.;+-bnUmrE " _ \ H$x:Efl Effi ?F Hffi ,€.AHf ?S ZEfi B!}fr +U fr , H. fvfr ^n {dI ffi flJX i At E ffi +F g,H. ffi X S} ++ 2 ft . lfinB ? ffirff; ffi E' FiE#f x + ffiEwMe,B ffi x tr F.tfrMffi *HElr ^ffiF,'E E ttru 6f[ ZWIfrtJ HHEflI# " ffi l+ rfrna ? tr +Hn ?{f 'ffiE/....?.ffi rX+A#ffiffie,Bffi*Stffi2fr.{fr.t k rffiro Fl X t +t #ffi +fi e E ffi X Sj M ZF,mffJ ffiFJ tffifli il lil D/ ff| i6 " (-) x+ilEffiffisBffi.asfffizefr n*r.RiffiHW+fie,8 ffi * frn lnl ft. ffiffi nE t &ru tr KgEfrllrFs*a ) +fE H' axiat#ffiffie,Bffi Afl ' Hfl$lf+WBmZffiEfri*ffiTri, , ffiffi,Tffiffi4lEH4 fr!ffi e,H. M " m-ffi H4'E+EF}IF H!?rlEZ' Hff; ltrH' mF r H ffiffi€ I ( positive theology ) " Eltl& nFnE r ff; if +ZR ffA +fr . *aAit,if itr R-ti z ft-+.*E+trAEflfr ls5 il'+ ' ft.El ArrFftE?/-, fr-ilF/...'.ie'$* " tFdr.$..f ffin, falF nff inf i f-- /-&+^H -,u " H=ff i f f i4fsF rE#iF€.r ( specurative theology ) , ftffi'{re. fitffiEffiffiffi{+#HFnHHfflY" rtffitr fr# ' ffEfifH$*{jiJfrrJ$filq#ffifrl#H'" Ft r E.#if s r mF ' axlat#ffiif gE ffiilg ' iFE u*ffiffiziFg,E ffi HEffi " *ffiffittr : r af +fttg,t*E|itF )y,Fp. , IEgrtT 6t )E h ,' ' &EZ ' FiED/ zffitfi #H- r E1ll r fr! H ffizytr , frRffiIND}ffiffi, D)fgffiIEIW " ffiD) ' FJilfiZE,-^ffJffiEfrfi ffiftEfc r,Et#lf4r H4 " iE ffi ,|E Eifr,E. ffi * SJffi E! E {U' ^H + E ffi € E Hf!+F E €. 1fiffi'W.eFlf'++F€.€UEHf.nffJkUrZEfr.' lEIffi ' ffil r Hffi r Bm r ( revelation ) D)@F\+ErL' if HqFfif;#g frffi,ffifiH!)lE E, ffiffiffi,frkJBr^trEfl t 1RRffifiF-#H!ffiHE-59W " {EiE ffi |E s ifr,B ffi X Sl ++ trr ft.lfirlf &H Hffi & " T X t) ifi Z : 1. IFHM#BffiAffMZiEfi I+MfrHffi ffi effi ? Hffi tFe,Bffi X vfrn'IEIE{utF rE ? E +HzcEffiWrlffi r Hffiffi€fr!,Effi#f iFeHffi t h. r Hffi+F eHffi *sltF wfr.lfi.r FFff Jilnvtms " (I) fi EH?+IFH!Bffi #I/HE Eru HffiiFgtFffiAfAUtfrffiEil ( Prato, 427-347 B.c. ) Zffift frft ' #tfitrEilt#gffiT ( ptotinus, 205-270 ),E m, h.D)Btrffi. l-=.1qffiHrefr!4trJ ( nugustine,354-$0) Z+fig,E m frrffi, " 4ff u Hiiru des Wones:Zur Grundlegung einer Religionsphilosophie, p.206. \t Et , pp.2o5-2o6. \.. t m#+ , ( f f igf f iR) ( 6Jt : JtE,tss4) ,46g1 " \ 156 f; f l ,*fat &Aiht';tnrk,{g-f6iB€.+F+ T g T H ffi A fi flHffi tr,8. M XzE ry,E. M h.\8A H! ft +f.8, ffi ' {E fu HrF,ftW,Eh,H.#ff fr trFnil.ff fr!+F, ffil=- lqruiF H',tfu *., ttFfi*rs': I E,l+-'a_*+,+E+,gt4}. *-"t-#ip-*p"1 Ra , ft4ttn ilh fl*o'4 P"l fE htr-atild rfr t frlelif , g)t&.Fftfitrv hn &tr&fi+f 6,.t ffi X.tr, + 6 ty,t*RttAEF.Ii ltv, kh tg,.,lLz^ h?,n^-{,& '6&?f 'frle vxl€Iry +ffirh rE,lLet€HA ft *ll-alry g)# +.e.+46t j i fF. - r tr ft ' W,EfrT trH+F +,8 fS?gET tr ffi ffi }*J-X4H X -AK ffitf, , F.hUI)trX-#ffi , FnI\, r?g.-d,hr{.Fts€ tt+, 'o ; & FitE -#' f!H'lS,Z', 1EWH+FW | ;t'pp^l ( illumination ), + frU, EfUFtrf!-aKffi ; lEffi ' #ffiF!ffi## EHFiEl;=-ffi' F/tEEtsffi tF " tr th, ftU|r'g.HA+FF'AH ' tfi;EAro,L'frkJZ^frffif4#f$ffi ' it tX+Fffi ffitkE fr! ' X;.ft;H+frtrtT+E " Jos6 G6mez caffarena fl+iA ffiW+fi84fr!;;frffifffF tffit%irt#.t ' f&EElHil" 'I VL+'d.#ht^.fr-&+ft)d ' fr.* ++:iF4FF,*1ilr: hlft_4*-a 6i " q.-'ni#r,fH+F *,4t: ^-#lA+hu,Afrt , v\k * Y.ft T ifr ffi /.?-T4 ( rr, 6 ffi €,f *a*&,re rf € r'l 6i R H q ffi u\ rl Z ' +ft' ( + Eg g,E ffi + filxEfr +F x 6 Jt z wft#g, rssr ), zzs-226 F" 'o dF#F , (?FgfsR) , 4s H " ' ' Jord G6mez Caffarena , "The Proofs of the Existence of God ",Karl Rahner with Cornelius Ernst and Kevin Smyth, Edit. Sacramentum Mundi: An Encyclopedia of Theology, vol.2 (New York : Herder and Herder, 1968), p.396. + ffi . *q ^J *t,if 6-t R.,E : 'e-+, *.8 + tt A E+*ft ts7 F) , *,=#*a*l -*rRfi !&,+.&, {o&€rb}t+k*"x 1l++\l?16t ' -,$tfr.-l@i+rRffi f+6 " t th*lV.ffitffi ( Bonaventure, r22r-r274) fr,ffitsT WffiTtr+fi efiffifrrJ+trfrffi1fr , tft;E : r if +T. ft1ytLfti-attphl il.W. , {a ft-^i 6i,S,* r " o (2) fi-##eBffiAfi#2ft.{n H#+F HE ru W IRA fr I+ M ? ^ H ff +F ffr fr. {fiZffi € x E {t M ? #H7l?frH?Wrlffi r H#+fi+FEffllHtr r h. I H#+Fe E ffi *ff ++frrJft.{fir ffi *11J} IJEUffis " a. Hffiffi+REF9mEl Hffi ++efr rot'+^tt#d X' itfr ,Bt#+Fe Yt ffi,H fi., H HE -frHfrPfU+Zqfi#d4fi( winiam ockam, rzss-r34s ) 6! r nE Z-#.1 ( nominalism ) f.jrlE'f+frrJTl=-ll:' fr-Hftffitrffi.Att #frEffiFdEEf! #W , ,Z,r1wnv.#gh.*.',*-{nfr!,E f it E ^ H +ffiryffiBEroF , D}fr1Bffiil.ffiif# " b. HffiM+BffiXHffiz'€& Hffi+fr€,E ffi X.ftl4ts4H[Tf!,8 M#m ' r i+,if *lAAi E,in ff_if*lAf.1,g.ga ' fA-iif. iFtiiE-E ht a #.2*,dni$i,u 4f ZBil dn ft,L'r{ti?#if ht *,A4^ . El tL , l.-fr2f,t4;s+4+ f gE,if *a €' €,-$b fr.?f *1,\60 *L,g " fr ,\6i *A*&,l44 E t,lAiet €. Efi+f+H€ f F rtu t " " Ffil:)' H#tFg,E MXrcH#.WfrE ffiEUEtEIF Zffir;&.*tF.F + f! r HHE6 r " ,, ff i6+ , (ff igff iR) ,4s 11 " ' t ( 8,t998) '850-851 H" ( f f ief f i f t ->\alr ' ; r ls8 Ff,,Sr) irfrrlr{.i*.n&#q'6rr,g€.ffi+ ffiA E z' H#+Fe,E,ffi XStt+ ffJft.lfi.flffiT - effitu, trtr!ffiFtJ t ffi]--l#+W-F*#' tRfrU,#E r Hffi+Fe r ft!ffi fu : r FAE gf *ue* WfuH . E4S.f T B-E-EA{.\++,\ ' fil. +*&rt,\tre , l*-t.d' '-+tiLI€*iF4=+i^i, 'o o y1n frrtre-i+ffi T H#+Fefr!ffi€ffi*z\' r FeEif + Z++ e, ft- af fteifr,'fi-llxft&* " Ftffirtutrft-4f {aiF,\AAfi FH t " 2. ffig+ffiSffiffi.affiffizEfi ,f+ME,Ef.#+fr +UU ? ^ H,H.ffi iHfl {Hffi IdI ?,E.'f+FE,Hffi XY ,Eln|ft.{fr}frnn? #tr.7lffiWt}ffi r,E*fiFgftli#fliF t h. t,Eff ffi e,Bffi Xff+fiWfr.|frr ffi fl ii trtXms " (I) ,89+#Sf!,8ffi;f;tiH EEEilJ tfrlfA*,BMX)Eq& ( phlo, 2s-s0 ) ffiffigfiSet6^ ffi#' +dFlt n-tr-H -IEEIJEi' ff ffiAtEfrrEZ r ffiAi-fr r &H-E'ff &'E ( Aristotle, 384-3228.c.) 2r gl)JE I ,8.,€ ' +5i r H E&-frrt h ' f,l€-a H €LtH, kgrt fi fr.4uif,+h ' fr€Lt e,A #J rL 6t#fu FlogosJ -, " o JEt&Em ffi,ffiffi-{Eeuffig,Etfr t ffi, ffi ,8, ffi X' ff Ff, B 7 + tr fd,E, ffi XW++f! # ffi Z' 4g'El,H, fff tH rt wftfr+ " (2) Efl+#IFEffi*Si#ze{fr. ,E #ffi g |n7.-i At ffi Hffi ffi g?9, t?W"ffi€ D,{ &ffiffi trr E. 'o dF#+ , (ff igff iR) , s9;1 " ' ' dFff iH, (Ei+g:g€;fr) ( 6Jt : ps#E , rsTs) , lOs11 " +fr . *iA *t,if 6.t F.tz z ft,F*E +{r A EE+*fr lse f;rffi;frfr trt t 4 " Ftlf frl4Hm E' ruE ffiT trEff &'EYt t- e f! H tt4, 1ff f.{f.ffYtrtf ft H IE " FiF}tf f! --#f m =, TE8.F T EEEffi &'ffitr!ff ffiffi ,Bffi ' +'FH,IS+ H-FNRH #ffifE )r, T#FXtftl)EffHFfi4-#ffi- W+WJffi 4H . H# frfH{E " lElffi ' H'Eh&4IXEiEfAffifr!)6ffH ,ffiHBflft+fifr!f;r ffi,, Fn D)&IEffi#r z I i+ + ft-rg-'lLf,rf! trv )tta?.TF?,fg,ltr 4F ffi ff , E Ert!'ftv |Eif +, &-ltl-a{rr&€iF .ry E E ?r. art t'u " Ffrffi EA++#Effi E-' tbff"e T MLL+trEhYt -LEl Rftr4, ff" ffi,Lh.*. IFffi-#ffi (EPH&f! TEF&;6EHI ) ' D/fgffiE'FK!ffiRFH#FJ ' ttriffi H €U EiE'lE ffi R frlH E-tf WEE " H #b &ffiffiE+Fe trrffiffi?[' &ffi H'14 f!,E t# r)fr?, Ffr D)tfr ^H.EiE F tr ffi e -# fS zffi E *fr+F e " ( - ) fr fit ff xEilEffi m sffi ffi. *ytfrzEfi fi! lfr +!| ffi ro E Kg E ffi {H$g# ) + Ffr+EH ZXt ffiHffi++e,B.m F0#t6" , #Hzr ffifr[H-#.EE , ETttlEEFffiFzqFJHil , ff ffiiEZqFJrl$ltlT : r. ff rEilfA+fif!H*YtL?fr!ffffir fr tffimffi"JFEfr#r iE ffi t Zffi {#{r nft,ft)FH #lf-frrt,'fr tfr ffizr ffi 4 fZ. F.lF ffi-flit|#ff ffi fff finft H ft ffi ffi 2L " ffi= Z' fff' r {F ffiHffir ( Glaubensbegrtindune ) frll$f fttfl'r..,fi ft,e*?fi ffi TU " zT'EF if iE H fr,rl -#,EA ffi I+ M Wtil @ tr A,1. 4 Yt ffi,tfffi ,a' t#fi ffffifr!-ryro6 " 'u tF6+ , (+figffiR) , 44 H "t' Hrjr", Des Wortes: Zur Grundlegung pp.32-36. eine r ReIi gtonrpnihfuu, w160 f; f,,*f ,z} *ed:.flr{'i{ &4e+6i,e.ie.+F+ 2. h. ^i& *S # ^ H 4 Hffi fi , ffi I+ MEtft t* F- ffi E H T Ft hz EFUf!ffi'l+fiffiEffib!.#W " &E Z, fr:t7.HiF^tfi,'tre^ iE F EX 4 REd;ru 6fr f!#ffi Z Fd tr! BAI# " 3. -e.H *t r&:#HA : )"ffi lt@ftffirarctuilr#H+#ffi,t' fF +fr.ffifr.,X,rF E ilE H H tr z\, tr['.El,R, FE E ilE E H tr zr X fi H H Effif;nffi " +4-Ez. , ^ffi1+ME.l#-f-ffidffi##nnt4. lR,rEEA iUffi h.^rc#H LEil ft.ryE/. ffi*.iE,E Fd ffi " 8tffifr.ro#H ,El+lEJ--{EEF+H}fr#882ffi ( m 4r Hffi tF e + ffi fU W, lF ffis{E tr! H 4 6rH Z E g 7€ EEf Etr',tFtfriEffi +H ), fll,y,,r1rc ^flAtr fr #, =frEA ^H#ffixY+n)EB-t,ffi-RF4 " - . $ftr,lt+#&BHfEffE+tr2 fEffiffif;r E,€ *w4fr28fiH!tjb+U tr ro rnF|ttr flj4'l+=#frtr*EF,ffi ffi z I HtrtF-# r,H MXr.j++ 2fr.1fr.n8 ? tfffi+frffiE' F/[E#H4'lt t #FB *.E,g] ffitr Zr 9trffi-# t E tr'tr.iefr.|fr+fiffi ' *EtE f! r ffi -R'EL r' r ffim'l$ t B-HHH! r ffi'Wts-|nffiffi -1 ( supernatural existential ) " ffi I+ MxE ? tr #Hrr,tLlfrEr| ffi r Httl# h.ffi*E#1ffi ffiZ r E ffffii-ft l ,E fS X.W+FZft.|fr. t &. r ffiruf'}4'l+t#e E*Egrffitr 2 F H *iF;S r ,E MXH+F 2fr.1fi.ffJ{lft,FJ: ffi*|] J}bNLXHil " (-) tr,lt+#&BFEEI[+ff2 rEffi?Tffir ffi,€.*#il ?HZEfi fronB'fLf # h.ffi#EFrffi ffiZ r H tr++;-fr r,H.ffi * F-'ln +ffi . *if i*t, i f 6f E,lz: 'e.R&18+{lAE-?+*ft 16l la|ft.{fitFW t #E frl4,lS ' ^H +4,1S+#,H Mfl+ffitXtExitrffiffiFrt ' ##ftrA#Jhtfi' x;frffi,il,*F!tr4 ; Effi ,E;rt#H\'rtr-ft. ^W#tr.' frlf+*ttrl#^ tr4ffi , fl))+ sl D)+ft2 (trexffi=) m=ffi rb{r : ffi,f:t€ , 1997) , r794F1" t62 f; fi,+r) JgA.frl.ittret+fitr,g€#+ rl- ' +ft a lAE+ ? rg,l+i#.*k1+6{}fr'ta}t +tLi+F#cl+#rL r'o , ft,rf ' (EfrlfrH+U#8,8ffiXtKffifrEfrtJ?-ffiffiH ( Anselmus or Canterbury, 1033-lI}e) E (Sl-Ffiffi) (Protogium) +ffiffifrZf1fl +FE&,W;Ffrffi' Effi-#ffi 'lhKKfrtrW,( Gonfried wilhelm r-eibnez, t&6-t7 16) @ffi H Jtrffiffiffi 88++8tr " ffi'ffiE ( #{ffiH'l$+trfU ) ( Critique of Pure Reason ) +f$ftffiffiH r EH effiffi I ( ontological arsument ) t' o iE'fE ;fr ffi Fi € F 4 ro D/ H{+,H *tr fr! ffi ft X ffi H lS H! tr HFE. , .^EHA* ffiflJiE,IE;frffitrF ffiz$H*gffi ffiH W, mD)tri*ffi EE r ffiW'il,*tr!#H- if t ZEE" ; frro & +ft fU iE ffi tr iiE tb X ffiH.Fn F-'{+trrffi tffi,,S E 4 ild ^ft H # fr! " fEJ g #frffiH.( copreston ) ffi =FPaft #ffiW,frHg+#f!;.ftffi*ifi4[T" t ;,tBtfE : lFEfl tQ.H ^EI VM{^YL+tuW_ffiXA " 4.8tffi : iE'lEl t?.H ^EI UM,ffi.LE+tE[Ht A'il'ff.EE, TF. E&ff 'bruffiffia+ ' lElwe6trt',L.fl.plEtF " ffi i-ft : trffi++#tr ,4EE4,L.ruH0H,A+ ' m'E.eF.lt ,L.llfflE4 " ffiA E Z' E'Elt#,E ffi XF.#E/\F!4E,IS' ff ttjtr ffiH ffi * ffi+lJ # ffi.{=- lq ffi ffi dt' E m E fr.* ffil-=- lW + fr! E'l+ fr 4 fZ. ZEE" 'o (EE+# ) , ff i trff ig#ffff i ;q.€, HfdlEr ,s2e H "t' Itn-unuel Kant, Critique of Pure Reason, Trans. by Norman Kemp Smith ( London and Basingstoke: Macmillan and Coltd, 1929 ) , pp.500-507. " FJt-,pp.5oo-501. t3 Frederick Copleston, A History of Philosophy, vol.Il ( America: The Newman Press, 1950 ) ,p.162. fffi . *iA it,ifftr R.& z ft.+.ev+$A E'+fr 163 2. g*Ef,ffitrZ rEf,*ffiFf,t BffiAHmZEfi l+rfift r EfttHifrr nE? nH,B#ffitr2 r Hftffi-#.r ,E' M*frrn{qlE{fiffis8? ffi# r Hft+S-#: 'E-ffiffi#ffi{F={tq Efitr H ftf[Ifl'l+ff!,E ffiiffi ' Itrfltr,E MX+IF r *f *ll6t ffi 4i.t *E A ft4+daiFPftffia,* * ,'o o ttrfltr,E ffitff! ffi'T:,ft]. -b E+/\ U #d fr! ffi il+l' I F ffi q H' ffi #Ffl e ffi ffi'Tt H BE+EF zt#ffiury^ffi,ffiffi# ' ltrl+r1E+F.tffiffifr!€uEa ' {Ei+ ftEilE+ffi21h ' FTFTF ,#-WffiEft,f+EfT ,WJF+ ffiiE'fE )\tffiffi,HT +ffi ' +F+ftTtt7#tlF " ltrMFnflJftfrrJ+ ffi ftfrJ ft,#ffift+-, T.ffiF- #Tt lr {dJtrlE#, m D)Etr#ffi.ffi f z- rtJ fH frn*k fE'l!fir|, TlEf.&#,w' Rf.El& ETAHfrT "Jf A$J " F:ANEIqIEffi#