Journal of Chromatography B, 877 (2009) 2135–2141
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Chromatography B
journa l homepage: www.e lsev ier .com
Column ra
Cordyce
He Ni, Xi
Guangdong Pro China
Guangzhou 510
a r t i c l
Article history:
Received 3 Ma
Accepted 7 Jun
Available onlin
Keywords:
Cordycepin pr
Cordyceps mili
Column chrom
Macroporous r
Solid fermenta
Medium waste
ainin
re di
phic
for f
ater
rous r
amid
er for
d to c
ion p
CCE method has high extraction efficiency, uses a minimum volume of solvent and can be used for both
quantitative analysis and large preparations of cordycepin from waste. The preparation method is simple,
highly efficient, energy-saving, environmentally friendly, and has been demonstrated to be effective for
large preparations of cordycepin from waste with low equipment and operating costs.
© 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduc
Cordycep
sinensis, wh
multiple ph
anti-aging,
in cultivatio
price of C. s
ity product
been demo
have simila
itaris has be
through sol
50–60 tons
China. The
10-fold exce
C. militaris.
waste and p
and bioactiv
1/1000 dep
∗ Correspon
E-mail add
1570-0232/$ –
doi:10.1016/j.j
tion
s militaris belongs to the same genus as Cordyceps
ich is a well-known traditional Chinese medicine with
armacological functions, such as immunoregulation,
antitumor and antimicrobial activities [1–3]. Difficulty
n and limited supplies resulted in an increase in the
inensis to US$ 12,000 kg−1 in 2006 for an average qual-
[2]. In contrast, C. militaris is easily cultivated and has
nstrated to be the best substitute for C. sinensis, as both
r chemical components and medical functions. C. mil-
en widely cultivated for production of fruiting bodies
id fermentation with a reported annual production of
of dried fruiting bodies in the Guangdong Province of
rice-based, solid fermentative medium is required in a
ss to the fruiting bodies produced in order to cultivate
Large amounts of used solid medium are discarded as
ollute the environment. The waste contains mycelium
e substances with a cordycepin content of 1/10,000 to
ending on the fungus strain and cultivating condition
ding author. Tel.: +86 20 8521 2630; fax: +86 20 8521 2630.
ress: li haihang@yahoo.com (H.-H. Li).
[4–6]. Thus, utilization of the waste media is of both economic and
environmental important.
Cordycepin, a nucleoside analogue of 3′-deoxyadenosine, was
first isolated from C. militaris [7]. It is classified as an anticancer
compound [2,8–11] but also has immunoregulatory [3], antibac-
terial [12], antifungal [13], antiviral [14,15] and anti-infection [16]
properties. It has also been shown to protect neurons from ischemic
injury [17] as well having various other functions [1,2,10]. Cordy-
cepin incorporates into RNA and causes premature termination
of RNA synthesis, making it a valuable tool in the study of gene
transcription [2]. Because of its cytotoxicity to terminal deoxynu-
cleotidyl transferase positive (TdT+) leukemic cells, cordycepin is
under clinical tests as a therapeutic agent for the treatment of TdT-
positive acute lymphocytic leukemia (OncoVista, Inc., San Antonio,
TX; granted by the US FDA in July, 2007). Cordycepin is also used in
various health products worldwide and its cost has recently risen
to US$ 4000 g−1 due to increasing demand.
Although cordycepin can be chemically synthesized, microbes
like C. militaris are still its main source. Several extraction methods
have been developed to extract cordycepin from a fermenta-
tive solution and from fruiting bodies of C. militaris, including
ultrasound- or microwave-assisted extraction, pressurized extrac-
tion, soxhlet extraction and reflux extraction. Wang et al. [18]
compared thermal reflux and ultrasound-assisted extraction with
water or ethanol and found that the thermal refluxing extrac-
see front matter © 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
chromb.2009.06.009
chromatographic extraction and prepa
ps militaris waster medium
ao-Hong Zhou, Hai-Hang Li ∗, Wen-Fang Huang
vincial Key Lab of Biotechnology for Plant Development, College of Life Sciences, South
631, China
e i n f o
rch 2009
e 2009
e 13 June 2009
oduction
taris
atographic extraction
esin
tion
a b s t r a c t
Large amounts of solid medium cont
militaris through solid fermentation, a
developed a new column chromatogra
this waste and a preparation method
imbibed in four times its volume of w
were directly separated with macropo
precipitation, crystallization, and poly
were obtained with 12 volumes of wat
through 3 different columns designe
following the separation and purificat
/ locate /chromb
tion of cordycepin from
Normal University,
g cordycepin, used in the industrial production of Cordyceps
scarded as waste and contaminate the environment. We have
extraction (CCE) method for the extraction of cordycepin from
urther separation and purification. Dried waste material was
for 6 h, transferred to columns and eluted with water. Eluates
esin DM130 columns followed by purification steps, including
e column chromatography. Extraction rates of more than 97%
a single column and 4 volumes of water for eluates circulated
oncentrate cordycepin. Cordycepin (98% pure) was obtained
rocesses, with an overall recovery rate of more than 90%. The
2136 H. Ni et al. / J. Chromatogr. B 877 (2009) 2135–2141
tion with water was the best method for extracting cordycepin
and polysaccharide from the fruiting bodies of C. militaris; three
90-min extractions with a sample-to-water ratio of 1:10 each is
optimal. Song et al. [19] reported that the main factors affecting
cordycepin
extraction t
for ultrasou
20% ethano
ods for the
C. sinensis a
are similar
or boiling w
was greatly
tures. Xia an
cordycepin
employed a
treatment f
sample-to-s
solid C. mil
macerating
extraction e
energy cons
The repo
cepin are b
column chr
tion amoun
pure produ
cordycepin
method req
In this
highly effic
for extracti
as a prepara
cordycepin.
cepin with
and in large
offers man
high extrac
mal volume
environmen
2. Materia
2.1. Materia
Solid wa
the cultivat
1 kg of rice
0.2% KH2PO
powder, 0.0
before it wa
fruiting bo
medium (a
d. Dried wa
833�m and
Cordyce
MO, USA).
Jackson Inc.
DM101 resi
dong, China
grade and w
analytical o
2.2. Ultraso
As a con
tion of cord
ruitin
ry.
ions
es of
room
t of 1
ent (
ntain
. The
lumn
olid
bibe
rred
uted
ns, e
naly
.
cycl
oun
sed t
the next material and the third fraction was used for elut-
second column (Fig. 2). Through this cyclic method, the final
ing solution was only four times the volume of the dry mate-
hile the columns were eluted three times (each with four
the volume of solvent) and almost no cordycepin remained
columns.
atic adsorption and desorption of cordycepin with a
orous resin
resins were pretreated with the following procedure before
e resin was first imbibed in de-ionized water overnight.
bsorbed resins were soaked sequentially with 80% ethanol,
l l−1 HCl, and 0.1 mol−1 NaOH, each for 4 h or more and
d with distilled water after each soaking.
gram of pretreated macroporous resin, with surface water
ed with a paper towel, was added into 20 ml of extracts
justed with HCl or NaOH) in a 150 ml Erlenmeyer flask and
ted at room temperature with shaking (120 rpm). At 10 min,
, 30 min, 40 min, 60 min, 120 min and 180 min, 0.5 ml of
n was taken and centrifuged at 4000 rpm for 5 min. The
extraction are the volume ratio of solvent to sample,
ime and ethanol concentration. The optimal conditions
nd-assisted extraction of cordycepin use 33 ml g−1 of
l for 102 min. Yang and Li [20] compared three meth-
extraction of cordycepin and other nucleosides from
nd C. militaris. They found that extraction efficiencies
by liquid extraction using pressurized organic solvent
ater extraction. For some nucleosides, the efficiency
increased using water extraction at ambient tempera-
d Wen [4] tested the microwave-assisted extraction of
from solid C. militaris medium. The optimal conditions
sample to water ratio of 1:200 with a 50 W microwave
or 3 min. Zhong et al. [6] reported that the optimal
olvent ratio for soxhlet extraction of cordycepin from
itaris medium was 1:16. These methods are based on
extraction and are not ideal because of relatively low
fficiency, a large volume of extraction solution and high
umption.
rted separation and purification methods for cordy-
ased on ion exchange, activated carbon or silica gel
omatography [6,21]. These methods have low adsorp-
ts, low recovery rates and are not ideal for generating
cts. Chen et al. [21] successfully prepared high-purity
using preparative reverse-phase HPLC, although this
uires high equipment and production costs.
work, we report on the development of a new and
ient column chromatographic extraction (CCE) method
ng cordycepin from C. militaris waste medium, as well
tion method for further separation and purification of
Using these methods, we successfully prepared cordy-
a purity greater than 98% in both a laboratory setting
r scales at costs of less than US$ 100 g−1. This method
y advantages over the current technology, including
tion efficiencies and recovery rates, the use of mini-
s and concentrations of solvents, energy-savings and
tal friendliness.
ls and methods
ls and reagents
ste media of C. militaris cultures were generated by
ion center in our laboratory. The medium contained
in 1.5 l of nutrient solution (1% glucose, 1% peptone,
4, 0.1% MgSO4, 0.1% ammonium citrate, 1% silkworm
01% vitamin B1), and was autoclaved at 120 ◦C for 2 h
s used for cultivation of C. militaris. After fermentation,
dies of C. militaris were harvested and the culture
s shown in Fig. 1) was dried in an oven at 45 ◦C for 2
ste medium was ground and sieved with pore sizes of
/or 350�m.
pin standard was purchased from Sigma Co. (St. Louis,
HPLC-grade solvents were purchased from Burdick &
(Muskegon, MI, USA). Macroporous DM130, DM131 and
ns were purchased from Shandong Chemical Co. (Shan-
). The ethanol used in all experiments was 95%, food
as purchased from local suppliers. Other reagents were
r biochemical grade.
und-assisted maceration extraction
trol for the new extraction method, macerating extrac-
ycepin from the waste medium was used under optimal
Fig. 1. F
laborato
condit
volum
dark at
amoun
treatm
tion co
10 min
2.3. Co
As s
was im
transfe
and el
fractio
were a
eluates
For
high am
proces
extract
ing the
extract
rial, w
times
on the
2.4. St
macrop
All
use. Th
Fully a
0.1 mo
washe
One
absorb
(pH ad
incuba
20 min
solutio
g bodies of C. militaris cultured by solid medium fermentation in our
we determined. Dried media were fully imbibed with 4
water (solvent to sample ratio, v/w, pH 6.5) for 6 h in the
temperature. Water (60 ◦C) was then added to a final
0 or 20 times the volume and extracted with ultrasound
100 W) in a 60 ◦C water bath for 1 h. The extraction solu-
ing the waste medium was centrifuged at 4000 rpm for
supernatant was used for HPLC analysis.
chromatographic extraction
C. militaris waste medium is a water swelling material, it
d with 4 volumes of water (pH 6.5) for 6 h before it was
to chromatographic columns. The columns were loaded
using common procedures. Eluates were collected in
ach with a volume equal to four times the sample, and
zed by HPLC until no cordycepin was detected in the
ic CCE, only the first eluate fraction, which contains a
t of cordycepin, was collected as a final extraction and
o the separation steps. The second fraction was used to
H. Ni et al. / J. Chromatogr. B 877 (2009) 2135–2141 2137
Fig. 2. Cyclic
materials. F1,
eluates. Each fr
Only F1 was co
cordycepin
The adsorpt
calculated.
Once ful
containing
20 ml of 80%
orption solu
were calcul
2.5. Column
For sepa
resins were
distilled wa
time with 2
the sample
analyzed by
For purifi
crystals we
flowed thro
After the sa
distilled wa
evaporated
was then cr
2.6. HPLC d
An HPLC
China) with
software w
cepin. HPLC
(250 mm ×
v/v); flow ra
amount, 10
brane filter
other subst
standard curves. Peaks for cordycepin and other compounds in the
samples were identified by their retention times and co-injection
tests with their corresponding standard compounds.
ults and discussion
lumn chromatographic extraction of cordycepin from C.
is waste medium
extraction process was separated into two steps. The first
volved dissolving the target substances with a minimum vol-
f their ideal solvents. As the dried waste medium began to
after imbibition, the materials were fully imbibed in open
ers with 4 volumes of water for 6 h until the cordycepin
ssolved to its maximum amount (data not shown) and was
aded onto columns. The second step was to elute the tar-
stances from the columns with water. As shown in Fig. 3,
raction rates of cordycepin from C. militaris waste medium
ultrasound-assisted water maceration were 87.3% and 91.6%
and 20 volumes of water, respectively, while the extraction
y the
0 vo
ethod
ion w
than
optim
ion
wer
mate
to d
ed t
y im
. 4A
n 35
30 ◦
epin
BV h
ycep
to di
ant
chromatography extraction of bioactive substances from biological
F2 and F3 refer to Fraction 1, 2, and 3, respectively of the collected
action contained four times the volume to the dry weight of materials.
llected as an extraction solution.
contents in the supernatants were determined by HPLC.
ion capacity of macroporous resins for cordycepin was
ly adsorbed for 3 h in extraction solution, the solution
resins was vacuum-filtered. Resins were desorbed in
ethanol for 30 min. The cordycepin content in the des-
tions was determined by HPLC and the desorption rates
ated.
separation and purification of cordycepin
3. Res
3.1. Co
militar
The
step in
ume o
expand
contain
was di
then lo
get sub
the ext
by the
with 10
rates b
8 and 1
CCE m
extract
higher
To
extract
factors
of the
height
indicat
be full
6 h (Fig
betwee
(either
cordyc
and 30
of cord
height
signific
ration of cordycepin with macroporous resin, pretreated
loaded onto columns. The columns were washed with
ter until their pH was neutral, and then washed a final
bed volumes (BVs) of distilled water (pH 9.0) before
s were loaded. Eluates were collected in fractions and
HPLC.
cation of cordycepin with polyamide resin, cordycepin
re dissolved in distilled water. The aqueous solution
ugh a prepared polyamide column at a rate of 2 BVs h−1.
mple was loaded, the column was eluted with 3 BVs of
ter. All eluates were collected together and vacuum-
to 1/4 the original volume. The concentrated solution
ystallized at 4 ◦C.
etermination of cordycepin
system (Dalian Elite Analytical Instrument Ltd., Dailian,
dual P230 pumps, a UV230+ detector and analytical
as used for the detection and analysis of cordy-
conditions were as follows: column, YMC-packed C18
4.6 mm, 5�m); mobile phase, methanol:water (20:80,
te, 1.0 ml min−1; UV detection at 260 nm; and injection
�l. The samples were filtered through a 0.45�m mem-
before injection. Quantitative analysis of cordycepin and
ances was determined by their peak area based on their
efficiency o
were increa
with 12 volu
reached 98%
respectively
is necessary
From the
on the extr
effects of te
Fig. 3. Compa
assisted extra
represent sequ
CCE method were 77.5%, 89.1%, 95.8% and 98.8% for 4, 6,
lumes of water, respectively. The extraction rate for the
was 11.5% higher than that of the ultrasound-assisted
ith, both using 10 volumes of water, and was even 7.2%
that of the latter method using 20 volumes of water.
ize the conditions for the column chromatographic
of cordycepin from C. militaris waste medium, several
e tested, including imbibition time, the particle size
rial, extraction temperatures, flow rates of eluate and
iameter ratio (H/D) of the loaded columns. The results
hat 6 h was needed for the dried waste medium to
bibed (data not shown). Imbibition times longer than
), the particle size of the material (either ≥833�m or
0�m and 833�m, Fig. 4B) and extraction temperatures
C or 60 ◦C, Fig. 4C) did not have significant effects on
extraction. The flow rates of eluates (2 BV h−1, 6 BV h−1
−1) had limited but consistent effects on the extraction
in, in favor of a low flow rate (2 BV h−1) (Fig. 4D). The
ameter ratio (H/D) of material loaded onto columns had
effects on the extraction of cordycepin. The extraction
f cordycepin increased about 5% when the H/D ratios
sed two-fold. Cordycepin was not completely extracted
mes of water at a H/D of 2.5:1. The extraction efficiency
and 100% when the H/D was increased to 5:1 and 10:1,
. These results demonstrate that a minimum H/D of 5:1
for efficient extraction of cordycepin from the material.
results above, extraction conditions had limited effects
action of cordycepin in the CCE method. We tested the
mperatures, flow rates of eluates and H/D of the column
rison of column chromatographic extraction (A) and ultrasound-
ction of cordycepin (B) from C. militaris waster medium. �, , �
ential extraction, represents one-step extraction.
2138 H. Ni et al. / J. Chromatogr. B 877 (2009) 2135–2141
Fig. 4. Effects aste m
thickness: 833 (white
(white). (E) He riatio
on extractio
militaris wa
nificant effe
cepin (data
a componen
Based on
chromatogr
lows. Dried
833�m, im
ature (30 ◦C
an H/D ratio
rate of 2 BV
processing.
that more t
charides (da
Our res
method ha
obtained w
reported re
with less s
method can
the fruiting
fruiting bod
ing solvent
was tested
plant mater
green tea a
acuminate
completely
by HPLC) fr
of 30–60%
green tea o
from C. acum
method wa
extraction a
ical materia
3.2. Cyclic c
militaris wa
As show
from the ch
racti
conte
seco
f ext
circu
umn
. Thr
te o
, a va
or on
singl
atogr
vent
cy.
cycl
ed s
ns wi
aste
xtrac
ere
actio
of column chromatographic conditions on cordycepin extraction from C. militaris w
�m (black), and 350–833�m (white). (C) Temperatures: 30 ◦C (black) and 60 ◦C
ight to diameter ratio (H/D) of extracting material in columns: 2.5:1 (black), 5:1 (st
n efficiency of adenosine from the same material of C.
ster medium. These three factors showed more and sig-
cts on the extraction of adenosine than on that of cordy-
not shown). The main reason may be that cordycepin is
t outside of cells, while adenosine is within cells.
these results, the optimal conditions for the column
aphic extraction of cordycepin were determined as fol-
waste medium from C. militaris was ground to sizes of
bibed with 4 volumes of water for 6 h at room temper-
), and then loaded onto chromatographic columns with
of 10:1. The columns were eluted with water at a flow
h−1. The eluates were collected for analysis and further
Repeated experiments under these conditions showed
han 97% of cordycepin and more than 96% of polysac-
ta not shown) were extracted from the waste medium.
ults indicate that this chromatographic extraction
s a higher extraction efficiency compared to those
ith ultrasound-assisted water extraction or to previously
sults [4,6]; this increased efficiency is accomplished
olvent and simple equipment and conditions. This
also be used for the extraction of active substances from
three f
cepin
in the
ume o
which
ent col
(Fig. 2)
tion ra
97.24%
times)
cyclic
chrom
the sol
efficien
The
amplifi
colum
dried w
scale e
tests w
two fr
bodies of C. militaris (data not shown), in which dried
ies can be loaded directly onto columns with extract-
(water) without a separate imbibition step. This method
for the extraction of bioactive substances from several
ials, including polyphenols, caffeine and theanine from
nd camptothecin from the dried leaves of Camptotheca
Decne. With ideal solvents, target substances can be
extracted (until substances in eluates cannot detected
om their biological materials with 12 (4 × 3) volumes
ethanol for polyphenols, caffeine and theanine from
r 20 (5 × 4) volumes of 60% ethanol for camptothecin
inate Decne (unpublished data of our laboratory). The
s demonstrated to be particularly useful for the accurate
nd quantitative determination of substances in biolog-
ls.
hromatograph