单一制和联邦制国家结构形式的比较——以中、美为例_0

单一制和联邦制国家结构形式的比较——以中、美为例_0 单一制和联邦制国家结构形式的比较—— 以中、美为例 LegalsystemAndSociety ?????????????????????????c?????? 8484?????L?????? ?????? ???????????????c???y???????????????o???i???s?????L?????????o?????????????????i?????d??? ????????s?????? ???????????????????????c???????????e?????????2?????#?????????????c???????????d???????? ???????a???????m???? ?????s?????????d?????#???t?????????c?????????’?d???n???????????????m???2?????m???F?? ?????????????????????????? ???t?s?????2?i)034?????y?????2A ???????????c???y???????????????o???i???s???(?L?????? ???o?????????????????????????????c?d???????????????????? ?0?s?????eo???????????c?????s???????????S?t???#???d???? ?S?t???????????????c???????d?????d?????0?????l?????i???? ???????????????????c?e???????)?????????t???m?????????? ?????????????c?d?d?????I???????9?m???????????d?#?????m?? ?????h?t???????????)?????U???????d???a?????m???????????? ?????????}?a?????????????’?????}???????????m?e ???L???????????????????? (??)?????? ?????????????????L????Unus?4???????e?????????????? ???c?e???????I???2???????m??????????????????????????????@?d ???f???)???m???f???????????d?????????m???????0?s?????? ???d?a?????????????????????????????I???????s???????d???? ???????????????d?S???????????#?????2?I???????????d???????? ?????????????e?y???????d?g???????????3???????????????????? ?i?????????????d?????????????????m???????h|????L?d?I???’?n ???A?????????????????0???0?s?????????????????d?????????? ?f???????????????????g???U?l?????????????????????c?d?#?? ???????????I???????????????????????????????????????e?? ?????n?????????????m???n?????2?????d???????????????????? ???m?????d?4?????????????????)???????!?????????U???m???? ???!?2?????d???????????????????????s???d???????S???????? ???d?S???y?m?????????s???????7 (??)?????? ???????????????L??Focdus?d?c?????t?e???????????????? ?f?U???2???i?????????????????e?????!?????#?f?U?2?f?s?? ?????s?????????????0???????L?????????????????????e?I???? ???n?d???????????????s???#???s?d?????s?????????????d?????? ?s?????????????d?????????m???I?A???????e???????????|?c?? ?????????d???????????????????????????????l???2?????d???I?# ???????????d???????????????????d???????????a?i???????7?L ???d?????????d?a?i?????????????I???o???????!?0?s?d?????? ???????f?m???????7???m?d?????????????????????????S?????? ???????????????a?????????m???????????????????d???#?????? ?????????????g???7???s?d?a?i???????????I???????????????? ???g?????d?????e?t???i?????????????????d???????????????s ???i???)?????7?????d?a?i?????n?????????????d?????????????d ?????????????????????d?i???????S???????????????????????? ?????e ???L???L?????????????c?????? (??)?????????????c?????? ???l?????2???????d?????f????????2007???????o?????3???e ?????U???21009?o0592(2009)09-203?o02 1?o?????o?????????????? ?????)???????o???????????????d1982?????????????F?’ ?????281???????????????????????????0?s?d?????I???????????? ???n?d???s???}?9???????’?L???????????’|l?e89???????I?????I?? ???????????????????????g???????????d??2000???2?????A???? ???n?F??????i???????g???????L?????L?????n???????????????? ?c?d?i???????c???A81??????????89?e???????????????????m???? ???d?????4???????????????d?I?????n???-?7?????d?A???????n???? ?????????????????????????d???????????f?????-???d??????|??? ???y?????)?????!?????????d?????y?)???L?)???L?????????L???) ???????!???????????????e?????d?????A???????n64???L73?????? ???d?9?????????6?????????????s?????L???????e???????????? ?????????’?e?????’?????????????m???????2???????????????? ?g???????A???????????????????g?d???????????d?d?A???????n?? ????????????(????????)?????????????????-???????n???e 2?e?????o?????????????? ???????????????????d?????o?????????????????????????A ???????n???d?o?????????????????????S?d?d???????????????? ?m?j?????????????????????d???????A?????????y???L?????o?? ???d???A??????????l?????n???????4?????d?????a???????????? ?????????????f?)?o???)???????????e 3?o???????n???2???U ?????????d???????’?????????e?d?I???????????????d?????? ?????t???????2???????????e?????d???????????????????????? ?????????????????????????????????????????????????????c?d ?????????o?????????????????????m?????L?d???????????o???? ???????????????L?????????o?)???????????????????????????? ?????o?????????L?????s?????e?I?????????n?d?????????????? ??????????@?e???????m?????????????????????????d???????I ??@?2?????d???????m???????????????d???)???????????I?????A ?e???????2?????d???i???????????a?f???s???????????S???i?? ???7???m?d???????????????I?????????????n?????????’?s?????e (??)?????????????????????c?????? 1?o?????o?????????0?s?????????? ?o???????????????????????c?S?d?????d???????????????? ?f?????????d?????????????????????g?????d???I?m?????g???? ???d?????????????????m?????????L?e?????f?????????????d?? ????????????????????81?????a???o???)89?e?????d?a?????????? ??????81?????#j#????89?2?????????????????????????i???d???? ||?????????U????}|?????s???)???s?????e?o???????d?????????’|l?? 81?????d??????89?2???????????????o???????d???????????????? ???e?I?????d?????o???????????0?s???S?????????d?i???????? 203 h’gaISystemAndSociety ?t?t?????t???m!!!?2!??f????I?c?????? ?2?????d???U?e???????U?2???????u???????????3???????????????d?)???????n???d?I?-??????? ??????d???d?????s?g???????? ?????????e 2?o?????o?????????????? ?????????d?????????m?#???????????????????????????d?I ?????d???????a?????m???????????????????????????????d???? ???a?????????????????A?????????????????d???????????????? ?a???????????????d?a?????S????????????????@?e?????I???? ???????????d???????a?????m???????????????d?????????????? ???????????e???????I?????g?????????????????d???I???????? ?????d???I?a???????s?????????????????d?d?S?????????????? ?????????a???????????A?e 3?o?????????@???’?????? ?????????@???’?????????I?????U?????U???s??@?d?????? ?????????d???????????????????i?L???d???????????????????? ???d???????????i?????????????????????????????????????d?d ???????f???????????????d???????????????#???????d???????? ???????a???I???g???????m?????????e???????I?s???A?????? ???A?d?????????I?????????????????d???????????????????????e ???????2?????????????n???d???-???????????????????????d?m ?????)???e???????????????’???????????o?????????o?d?????) ???-???????????????????????????d?d???????????c?????????? ?????’?d?????????????????????????????d?d???????????2???U ???????????S?????d?????)???I?-???????????c?????e ?m?L???? ?????????????????????????????#?f?????d?????????????? ?m?????l???????????????s?o?d???f????@?e?????A?d?#?l?????I ?n???A?m?????s?d?d?S???????????e?2???????????????????c?? ???????????e?????????????f?????????????d?????????????m?m ???’???????????e???c?????I???????d???????????s???e?I?? ?????????????’?c?????????d?????????????????????????d???2 ???????????????????????e???I???s?????????A?d?????????S?? ?U???e???m???-???S?????h???????d???2???????????????????? ?j???d?????????????????????????d?????????????m?l???????? ???L???????????I?????????d???e?????????????????????????e ?????2 #??@???o?????????????????c???????o???d?’???????o2005(7)?o @?????????????????????2?????????e?d???????????????????#???S?d???????|?c?2 ?????e???????????|?c?e???????????????????????o???????????????s?o?????????????m?? ???????#???????????2?????o?????s?????|?c?o???????????????????????c?????????????? ?m?????s?????d?????????????o???????????e?????????’????89?d?????????S?????c?????? ???????????g???????????d?????????????????????????????o???????d???????????????? ?2???????U?????????U?????????????o @?????????????????l???m????????8F???????????????????o #??????A?d?2?????l???S???????????????????d???????????????????F???????????? ?????????????????’???????e?????d???o???????????????#?????L?2?????????????????? ?|?c?o???????????I?????o?i???????????s???????????e?????????????????????i?????? ???n???a???????????d?????????????2???????????????|?c?o?????????????????????????? ???o???????????????s???S?????d???????????????o #??????????????????????????????????o???f?????S?d???????L?????????2?????o?? ???????????????????L???????????L?’?L?????????6?????????o?2?????????????a???????? ???i?????????m???????????????o #??8?????o???U?????????????o?u???2???????????o2004?o #??????????????????????????????????L???????????????d?4?h?????I???????????? ?????????????o?????d?????????g?????????’?c???????????????????????d?????A?d?)???? ?????n???d???????????????????????????U?d?2???e??????????89???????u???????#???d?? ???????o #??8???s?o???????????????s?o???I?o?u???2???????????o2004?o#????8???o?????????????????????????????0?s?o?????o???2?o2007(4)?o @???U???d???????o?????????o?????????’?????????o2004?????o (?A????171??)?n???????????n?????L???e?????L???2?????????? ?????3?????????????????l?d???S???m?!?????3?2???-???????? ???d?d?4?m?!???????????????-?S???????d???d???????|???????? ?2???????m???????e ???L?????3?2???-???????????????g?? ????????????????(???n????81????89)?????????????????? ?????????????????I???2???3?2???????2?????o???????????? ???3?????????)?d?????????-???????????????d???????|?????? ?????????2?????o???????????-(?’?????-)???????????????? ?????g???d???-??????133???d????????133???d????130???d?? ?????????????????d?m??????129???e???????n?2 ?????d???????n?????h?t?????-?S?????????e?f?????g???? ???d?????3?2???n?????m?????????d???2????81???????????????s ??89???????????????n???d???-???????????????????????c???? ?????d?????l???2???????????L???????2???g?L???????o?????i?? ?s?L???2?????L???????????d?????????e?2????81?????????????? ????89??81?????????????????????y???????8?I?????m????89???? ???s???d???-?????????????????????@???d???c???????)?????? ???????S?????a?e?????o?d?????????n???????t?s???d?2?????e ?????d???-?????????????????????????????????e ?????d?m???e???????????S?????e?????????????????l???? ?y?3?????????????????????????s???o?????d?????d?????s???? ?????U?d???????I???e???????m???????????????e???????g???? ?????????d?????????e?????????????????????????????d?????? ???)?e???????o???????3?2???n?f?????m???e ???m?d???2?????????????o???????e???????????2???????? 204 ???????S?d?d?l???????????L?s???????????L???????????d?????? ?????2???????????’?????????????d????81???m????89????91?l?d 81????89??9?l?d???m??????81??????89??81?????389?e???????-?m?? ???????2?????c???d???m??????????????????????????16?l?d?d ?4?m?????????????-?????2?????????????????-?S???????l?? ?3?2?’?o???S???d???????????????????????????????e???m???? ?????????-?????????????????d???????????e?d?7???|???????? ?????????????l?????????????-??88?l?d?d?7???|???????????S ???c???????l????????????2?l?d?S?d?7???|???????????????? 10?l?d?????o?d???’?2?????-???????m?????????????????d?d?7?? ?|?????d???-???m??????????????????16?l?d???o???-?????2?? ???????????o???????e ???L???? ?????)?????????????????d?????????????????????2?????e ?????????????-?S?????????}???????d?d???????????????????’ ???????3?2?????????????????-?S?d?????d?????????3???????? ???????????????????????????d?????????n?????L???e?????L???2 ???????????????3?????????????????l?d?????2???L?????????e ?????d?????????-?????????????????2?d?????????2?o?-?????} ?????d?????????????????????????????o???|?????????t?????d ?????-?????2?????L???????2?????????d???S???m?!?????3?2?? ?-???????????d?d?4?m?!???????????????-?S???????e ?????2 #??@???o???)?????????????????????????-?S?????o???????????????2?????????o2004(12) #??@?????d???????o?????????????????l???????????-?S?????o???u?????o2005(9)?o #????????d?????o?????3???????L???-?S???9?g?o?????????o2006(2)?o #??8?????o???????????????-?S???????????s???o?????o????????2008(3)?o