Polymer-Controlled Crystallizati
Superstructures
By Shao-Feng Chen, Jian-Hua Zhu, Jun Jiang
1. Introduction
Recently, the synthesis of complex superstructures by organiza-
tion of building blocks acrossmultiple scales to form a wide range
of ‘‘mesocrystals’’ has attracted a great deal of attention.[1]
The traditional methods of colloid chemistry have proved to be
capable of controlling the sizes and polymorphs of inorganic
materials by changing reaction parameters, such as
temperature, pH, supersaturation, solvent, and simple inorganic
ions.[2] In contrast, biological systems are very effective at
controlling crystal growth, as demonstrated in discoveries on
mollusk shells, sea urchins, coccoliths, nacre, and others.[3]
Proteins and polysaccharides with complicated patterns of
various functional groups in biological tissues are believed to
play a crucial role in the formation of such complex forms.[4]
Many unusual hierarchical structures of inorganic materials with
high complexity and structural specialties can be artificially
world, exhibiting non
properties.[11] Investi
the ordered hierarch
understand the essen
materials with physic
As a similar substanc
aragonite phase. The
in biomineralization
In this Research N
in polymer-controlle
superstructures. New
polymer-controlled cr
selective adsorption o
mesoscale transform
matrix or a substr
combination with a suitable solution medium.
in Aqueous
soscale
lymers in
agent to
locks into
R
E
S
E
A
R
C
H
N
E
W
S
www.advmat.de
www.MaterialsViews.com
Hefei National Laboratory for Physical Sciences at the Microscale
lo
en
d
ni
a
en
a
bi
str
so
ve
iv
or inorganic–organic hybrid materials with structural complexity, structural
specialties, and improved functionalities.
540
DOI: 10.1002/adma.200901964
Superstructures
The most useful function of hydrophilic block copo
controlling crystal growth is their use as a directing
induce coded self-assembly of nanoscale building b
Department of Chemistry
University of Science and Technology of China
Hefei, Anhui 230026 (P. R. China)
E-mail: shyu@ustc.edu.cn
created by biomimetic mineralization, using such polymers as
2. Polymer-Controlled Crystallization
Media: Selective Adsorption and Me
Transformation to Highly Ordered
[*] Prof. S.-H. Yu, S.-F. Chen, J.-H. Zhu, J. Jiang, G.-B. Cai
Division of Nanomaterials and Chemistry
Shu-Hong Yu*
The origin of complex superstructures of biomaterials in bio
and the amazing self-assembly mechanisms of their emerg
attracted a great deal of attention recently. Mimicking nature,
hydrophilic polymers with different functionalities and orga
matrices have been designed for the morphogenesis of inorg
this Research News, emerging new strategies for morphog
trolled crystal growth of minerals, that is, selective adsorption
transformation for highly ordered superstructures, the com
synthetic hydrophilic polymer with an insoluble matrix, a sub
solution interface, and controlled crystallization in a mixed
highlighted. It is shown that these new strategies can be e
extended to morphogenesis and controlled crystallization of d
� 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
calcite is the most stable phase of the three
crystalline anhydrous phases of CaCO3, and
vaterite is less stable than aragonite. CaCO3
co-deposited with organic molecules from
the organisms is one typical biomineral
occurring in nature. It is widespread in the
equilibrium shapes[3,4] and distinct physical
gation of how nanoparticles assemble into
ical structures of biominerals is helpful to
ce of crystal growth and to produce artificial
al properties similar to those of biominerals.
e, BaCO3 is thermodynamically stable in the
use of these two minerals as model systems
studies is a hot subject.[12,13]
ews, we will discuss the latest developments
d crystallization of novel unique mineral
emerging methodologies in the field of
ystallization will be highlighted, such as the
f a designed artificial functional polymer in
ation, its synergistic effect with an insoluble
ate, or the air/water interface, and its
additives.[5–7] The polymers used include
synthetic double-hydrophilic block copoly-
mers (DHBCs), low-mass electrolytes, and
triblock copolymers, which are widely used
in biomimetic mineralization.[8] If the
pattern of functional groups is designed
to match some special crystal faces of one
material, the functional block can selectively
adsorb on them to hinder the growth of
the crystal and affect its final morphology,
then directing the mesoscale self-assembly
of nanometer-scale building blocks into
hierarchical superstructures.[5,7,9,10]
From the viewpoint of thermodynamics,
gical systems
ce have
iverse kinds of
c insoluble
nic crystals. In
esis and con-
nd mesoscale
nation of a
ate, or the air/
lvent are
n further
erse inorganic
on of Unique Mineral
, Guo-Bin Cai, and
Adv. Mater. 2010, 22, 540–545
R
E
S
E
A
R
C
H
N
E
W
S
www.MaterialsViews.com
www.advmat.de
are many uncer-
s noteworthy that
nctional groups,
ogy of inorganic
most fascinating
mation of helical
ribbons, mainly
supramolecular
ono- or polypep-
has been occa-
echanism in the
lical micrometer
uced in alkaline
nate helical form
reported that a
and silica leads to
r structures that
nd that further
along the rim of
rphs’’, including
lf-assembly is to
al surfaces; thus
strongly bind free calcium ions in the process of mineralization,
which alters the crystallization mechanism from ionic growth to
mesoscale assembly.[12g] The negative polyelectrolyte PSS tends to
adsorb on the positive (001) face of calcite. This adsorption leads
to the formation of a long-term dipole along the c-axis of the whole
crystal, which drives the dipolar arrangement of PSS-capped
nanoparticles into superstructures. In the presence of PSS-co-MA
(poly(4-styrenesulfonate)-co-(maleic acid)), the platonic calcite
crystals with pseudododecahedral and pseudooctahedral shapes
consist of nanoparticles and polymer incorporated in the voids in
the microcrystal.[22] A continuous evolution of the crystallization
mechanism from polycrystalline to mesocrystalline and then
to single crystalline in the presence of poly(ethylene oxide)-b-
poly(sodium 4-styrenesulfonate) (PEO22-PNaStS49) was investi-
gated, based on aggregation of nonoriented larger nanoparticles,
to oriented smaller nanoparticles, and then to classical
Oswald-ripening ion-to-ion growth.[23] A thin layer of polymer
on the fine crystallites of polycrystalline crystals (2.2 nm) and
mesocrystals (3.7 nm) was observed, which can be further proved
by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA).
Recently, a rigid DHBC, poly(ethylene glycol)-b-poly(1,4,7,
10,13,16-hexaazacyclooctadecane ethylene imine) (PEG-b-
hexacyclen), has been used as an excellent crystal modifier to
synthesize triangular Au nanoplates by selective adsorption of the
functional group of the polymer on the (111) face of Au.[24] In the
ole
no
h
en
es.
sio
BaCO3 units (Figs. 1a,c).
[21] BaCO3 fibers with
a diameter of 200–500 nm and lengths as long
as some millimeters are assembled from
brick-like elongated nanocrystals with
200 nm length and 30 nm diameter (Fig. 1b).
It is interesting that the polymer itself does not
form helices in the solution with or without
barium ions, thus, the formation of helices
must be a result of the interaction between
barium carbonate nanoblocks and the polymer.
This architectonic arrangement via coded
self-assembly relies on two processes. First,
the adsorption of the stiff DHBC onto the
favorable (110) faces results in a staggered
arrangement that is controlled along the
aggregation direction of the first three parti-
cles. Second, a particle approaching an
aggregate in the perpendicular direction is
presented with favorable and unfavorable
adsorption sites, leading to a twist in the par-
ticle aggregate. The overlay of these two
processes leads to helix formation (Fig. 1d).
A nonclassical crystallization is realized in a
simple polyelectrolyte-controlled mineraliza-
tion also. Polystyrene sulphonate (PSS) can
Figure 1. a) Them
of helical BaCO3 na
image showing the
vacuum, not repres
of the relevant fac
duced with permis
macroscopic superstructures, although there
tainties in the complicated assembly process. It i
functional group patterns, and the types of fu
have a significant influence on the morphol
crystals.[5,7,14–16]
Helical and spiral architectures are the
morphology that has chirality. Currently, the for
structures, including nanofibers, tubes, and
relies on the direct templating effect of
nanoribbons, screw dislocations, chiral acidic m
tides, and chiral gelators.[17]
Micrometer-sized helical calcium carbonate
sionally observed formed by an ambiguous m
presence of chiral/achiral polyaspartate.[18] He
filaments of silica-barium carbonate were prod
sodium silicate solution, while strontium carbo
grew in silica gel.[19] Recently, it has been
chemically coupled coprecipitation of carbonate
fibrillation of the growing front and to lamina
experience curling at their growing rim, a
propagation of these curls in a surflike way
the laminae results in the formation of ‘‘biomo
helicoids.[20]
An effective way to encode nanoparticle se
selectively adsorb additives onto specific cryst
‘‘programmed’’ self-assembly of nanoparticles
occurs. We have demonstrated that the
selective adsorption of a racemic phospho-
nated DHBC (poly(ethylene glycol)-b-
[(2-[4-dihydroxyphosphoryl]-2-oxabutyl) acrylate
ethyl ester] (PEG-b-DHPOBAEE)) onto the
(110) faces of BaCO3 leads to the formation
of BaCO3 helices by programmed self-
assembly of the elongated orthorhombic
Adv. Mater. 2010, 22, 540–545 � 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gm
cular formula of PEG-b-DHPOBAEE, which acts as a template for formation
particle superstructures. b)Magnified scanning electronmicroscopy (SEM)
elical structure. c) The primary nanocrystalline witherite building block in
ting the observed face areas in solution but just illustrating the orientation
d) Proposed formation mechanism of the helical superstructure. Repro-
n from [21]. Copyright 2005, Nature Publishing Group.
bH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 541
R
E
S
E
A
R
C
H
N
E
W
S
www.advmat.de
www.MaterialsViews.com
vaterite microspheres can be produced under control of the
artificial DHBC PEG(m)-b-pGlu(n) in N,N-dimethylformamide
542
case of mineralizing CaCO3 crystals, so-called pancake structures
were fabricated with a shape similar to the layered structure of
nacre in Haliotis rufescens, as shown in Figures 2a,b.[12d] Layered
crystals with different morphology and surface structures, even
disk-like crystals, can be obtained by altering the reaction
parameters in the system. This study suggested that the
morphology of the crystal is influenced not only by epitaxial
match between the polymer and crystal faces, but also by particle
stabilization, crystallization time, time for polymer rearrange-
ment, and surface ion density.
In another case, polycrystalline round discs of CaCO3
consisting of nanocrystals capped by poly(ethylene gly-
col)-b-poly(ethylene imine)-poly(acetic acid)-C17H35 (PEG-b-
PEIPA-C17) can form microrings by dissolution of nanocrystal-
lites at the center of the discs (Fig. 2c).[13b] At the initial nucleation
stage, the primary hybrid polymer-capped CaCO3 nanocrystallites
in the central part have a relatively high concentration of included
multiple chelating ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA)
moieties, and then the outer area of the discs is of lower polymer
concentration. With increasing aging time, the higher polymer
concentration around the primary nanoparticles results in
dissolution of inorganic nanobuilding blocks from the inside
to the outside, leading to formation of the microrings.[13b]
Figure 2. a) The structure of PEG-b-hexacyclen. b) A typical SEM image of
pancake-like self-stacked CaCO3 obtained after two weeks gas diffusion
reaction in the presence of 1 g L�1 PEG-b-hexacyclen, starting pH 4,
[Ca2þ]¼ 10mM. Reproduced with permission from [12d]. Copyright
2005, Wiley-VCH. c) A typical SEM image of microrings of CaCO3.
Reproduced with permission from [13b]. Copyright 2006, ACS.
� 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gm
(DMF)/water mixed solvent with a suitable volume ratio by taking
advantage of the synergic effects of the block copolymer and a
selectivelymixed solvent (Figs. 3a,b).[34] The property of themixed
solvent has been found to play a key pole in controlling the
growth, polymorphism, and shape of CaCO3 mineral.
[33]
Further study indicated that uniform ellipsoidal-like particles
with multiple thorns stretching out along different directions on
the surface can be obtained at 14� 2 8C in DMF (Fig. 3c), which
are quite different from those spherical structures formed in
aqueous solution.[35] In addition, aragonite CaCO3 crystals with
hierarchical tubular superstructures were obtained in DMFunder
suitable conditions at the lower temperature of 4� 2 8C, and
many small aragonite nanorods were observed grown on the
surface of large microtubes (Fig. 3d).
As the solvent quality for the polymer worsens in the mixed
solvent, mineralization in a mixed solvent can result in externally
triggered polymer aggregation, which will provide a new
additional experimental variable for controlling the morphology.
In addition, because the solubility product of a mineral is
simultaneously changed in a mixed solvent system, interesting
cooperative morphogenesis scenarios may be achieved.
4. Polymer-Controlled Crystallization on an
Interface: Growth of Unique Superstructures
Recent progress has demonstrated that the combination of
polymer-controlled crystallization with a suitable interface, such
as an insoluble hard substrate or an air/water interface, makes it
possible to access a variety of unique mineral superstructures.
The polymer PEG-b-DHPOBAEE with a different molecular
weight has also been used for mineralization of BaCO3 to
spontaneously form a concentric-circle Belousov–Zhabotinsky
pattern made of BaCO3 nanorods in solution on a glass
substrate.[36] The experimental evidence indicates that the
formation of the Ba–polymer complex precursor plays a key role
in the autocatalytic precipitation reaction occurring in a
reaction–diffusion system, resulting in the spontaneous forma-
tion of micrometer-sized periodic rings of nanocrystalline BaCO3
grown on the substrate in an aqueous solution.[35] The distance
3. Polymer-Controlled Crystallization in a Mixed
Solvent: A New Way Toward Hierarchical
Superstructures
Mineralization reactions in nonaqueous solution, such as simple
ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, and diethylene glycol, have been rarely
studied.[25–27] In recent years, several research groups have
occasionally focused on the use of different solvent media to
control the crystal growth of CaCO3 and other com-
pounds.[2b,28–31] CaCO3 nanoparticle aggregates, including
elongated or spherical morphologies, can be formed in a
water/alcohol solvent with various solvent compositions.[26]
Even though vaterite microspheres can be crystallized in water
solution using starburst dendrimers[32] and poly(ethylene
glycol)-b-poly(L-glutamic acid) (PEG(m)-b-pGlu(n))[33] as crystal
growth modifier, the vaterite spheres obtained are not uniform.
Recently, we have demonstrated that highly monodisperse
bH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2010, 22, 540–545
R
E
S
E
A
R
C
H
N
E
W
S
www.MaterialsViews.com
www.advmat.de
A continuous l
(ACC) with 5 nm
of Haliotis laevig
bundle’’ are clea
mesocrystals in n
small building blo
of ACC-PAA (poly
process. The film
ticles to achieve d
on polymer-direct
the polymer adsor
thin film; the pat
particular crystal f
carbonate and thu
It is well know
organisms is gene
molecules at the s
Figure 3. a,b) SEM images of highly monodisperse vaterite CaCO3 micro-
spheres mineralized in the presence of 1 g L�1 PEG(110)-b-pGlu(6) for
7 days at room temperature. The volume ratio of ethanol/water is 1/1.4.
CaCl2 solution (0.6mL, 0.1 M) was added to mixed solution (6mL).
between adjacent rings is almost constant (ca. 5mm), as shown in
Figure 4a. The numerical simulations using a Bru¨sselator model
for the reaction–diffusion equations qualitatively fit the observed
oscillating precipitation reaction well (Fig. 4a). This amazing
pattern formation underlines that it is possible to form a
spontaneously self-organized pattern in solution by a mesoscale
transformation process, which is similar to the patterns observed
in a variety of physical, chemical, and natural systems.
Reproduced from [34]. Copyright 2006, Wiley-VCH. c) SEM image of
ellipsoid-like CaCO3 crystals obtained in the presence of 1 g L
�1
PEG-b-pGlu after crystallization for 7 days at 14� 2 8C. [CaCl2]¼ 10mM.
d) Complex prickly superstructures prepared in the presence of 1 g L�1
PEG-b-pGlu and [Ca2þ]¼ 20mM at 4� 2 8C for 7 days. Reproduced from
[35]. Copyright 2008, ACS.
Figure 4. a) SEM image of the concentric circle pattern of BaCO3 crystals
[polymer]¼ 1 g L�1, [Ba2þ]¼ 10mM, starting pH 5.5. Reproduced from [36]
Wiley-VCH. b) Square microcontact printing areas with BaCO3 nanofibers s
Reproduced from [44]. Copyright 2009, RSC.
Adv. Mater. 2010, 22, 540–545 � 2010 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gm
study simulates the process by using an insoluble polymer matrix
as the crystallization site and a soluble polymer as a stabilizer for
chelating metal ions in solution. ACC was observed to first
deposit on the hydroxylated PMMA (poly(methyl methacrylate))
film and then crystallize in the form of polycrystalline films, with
the interplay of soluble PAA.[40] Metal carbonates (Ca, Ba, Sr)
formed on a PVA (poly(vinyl alcohol)) film in the presence of
soluble PAA have been shown to have a three-dimensional (3D)
relief structure.[41] Periodic concentric circles were formed by
oriented needle-like calcite nanocrystallites, the distance between
two neighboring circles being about 10mm and the height of the
circle about 5mm. Furthermore, the BaCO3 and SrCO3 needle-
like crystals can periodically grow further on the CaCO3 circles.
[40]
Combining the method described in this section with the
layer-by-layer technique, a nacre-like structure of alternating
organic and inorganic layers can be fabricated.[42] One CaCO3
mineral layer is deposited on the diazo-resin/PAA film, and then
the organic film is cast on the mineral layer again. Organic–
inorganic layered structures can be easily achieved by repeating
this process several times.[41]
Generally, poly(aspartic acid) or PAA (poly(acrylic acid)) is used
to induce the formation of the polymer-induced liquid precursor
(PILP), in which the polymer is thought to sequester and
concentrate the calcium ions and delay the crystal nucleation.[18]
For example, nacre-type laminated CaCO3 thin
film can be produced by heating a mixture of
PAA and ACC.[43] A general route for fabrica-
tion of patterned carbonates has been reported,
which combines the advantages of the micro-
contact printing technique and a PILP.[44]
Square and linear patterns were stamped by
microcontact printing with octadecyltrichloro-
silanon (OTS). A tiny amount of PAA was
introduced into the aqueous solution to take up
metal ions for formation of a typical PILP.
Calcite and BaCO3 (Fig. 4b) fibers stand on the
special, OTS-printed, square areas. Based on
the same idea, double-stranded and cylindrical
helical BaCO3 nanofibers lay on the OTS film
in the presence of a phosphonated block
copolymer (Fig. 5).[45] The double-stranded
helical fibers consist of two single helical
grown for 1 day.
. Copyright 2006,
tanding on them.
bH & Co. KGaA, Wein
ayer of stable amorphous calcium carbonate
thickness covering aragonite platelets in nacre
ata and a DHBC-directed aragonite ‘‘sheaf
r evidence of widespread distribution of
ature and how to organize mesocrysals from
cks.[12f,37] A free-standing transparent thin film
(acrylic acid)) was synthesized by a spin-coating
can adsorb organic dyes and metal nanopar-
ifferent optical properties.[38] In another